Choosing a Black and White film

 

 

Is this article useful to you?  If you think so,

please consider a voluntary donation.

 

Contribute via Paypal

 

More about donations!

 

 

Jump ahead to:

 

 

There’s a wide selection of black and white films currently available.  I recommend sticking with films from the two major manufacturers, mostly for availability reasons.  Kodak and Ilford films are available worldwide, so you can pretty much count on being able to get them anywhere.  It’s a good idea to standardize on one (or at most, two) films at first, until you fully understand the differences between films and can make informed decisions.

Tradeoffs

Relationship between speed and grain

In an ideal world, black and white film would have no grain, and have such wide exposure latitude that you could expose it at virtually any film speed and get good results.  In the real world, film is a compromise between speed and grain – that is, slower films have finer grain and faster films have larger grain.  For this reason, it’s wise to standardize on a film that’s as fast as you need but no faster.  For general purpose use with 35mm cameras (and when making prints no larger than 8x10) a 400 speed film is a good choice.

Tonal distribution

Different films render a scene differently.  Some films emphasize mid-tone and highlight separation at the expense of shadow separation (e.g. Kodak’s Plus-X).  Others offer very ‘realistic’ rendition (e.g. Kodak’s Tmax 100).  Note that ‘realistic’ is not always the same as ‘beautiful’.

Current choices

Kodak

  • Plus-X – a ‘long-toe’ film that offers good separation of mid-tones and highlights at the expense of  shadow separation.  Often used for portraiture.

  • Tri-X  - long a standard in the photojournalism world, Tri-X is the film to which all other films are compared.  Tri-X is a medium speed film which is very tolerant of adverse storage and handling, processing variation, and exposure.

  • Tmax-100 (aka TMX) – a very fine grained film with a very short toe, giving a very realistic rendition of tones.  Poor tolerance for underexposure.

  • Tmax-400 (aka TMY) – a fine grained, medium speed film which some consider to be a replacement for Tri-X.  Somewhat finer grain than Tri-X.  Less tolerant of processing variations than Tri-X. 

  • Tmax 3200P (aka TMZ) – a very high speed film for use in poor lighting conditions. (e.g. theater photography, indoors under poor lighting, etc.)

  • Tmax 400CN Chromogenic – a black and white film which can be processed by mini-labs as if it were color film.  Very tolerant of exposure errors.  Kodak’s competitor to Ilford’s XP2.

Ilford

  • FP-4 Plus – Ilford’s answer to Plus-X  (or else Plus-X is Kodak’s answer to FP-4).  Fine grain, 100 speed.

  • HP-5 Plus – Ilford’s Tri-X competitor.  Somewhat more realistic rendering than Tri-X.  Tolerant of processing variations, etc.

  • Delta 100 & Delta 400 – Ilford’s response to Kodak’s Tmax-100 and Tmax-400 films.  Finer grain, shorter toe (more realistic) than fp-4 and hp-5).

  • Delta 3200  - Ilford’s response to TMZ, just recently introduced.  Slightly finer grain than TMZ.

  • XP2 Chromogenic – a black and white film which can be processed in c-41 chemistry (color processing) in minilabs.  Very tolerant of exposure  variations.

Exposure

Adjusting the amount of light that strikes the film controls exposure.  If you have too little light hitting the film, you’ll get no image.  If you have too much light striking the film, you have a very poor image (or, in extreme cases, no image at all).  You have three ways of adjusting how much light hits the film: adjusting the shutter speed, adjusting the aperture, and changing the lighting.

Shutter speed

The shutter controls how long the exposure lasts.  Making the exposure shorter reduces the amount of light that strikes the film, making it longer increases it.  Slow shutter speeds allow for motion blur.  Short shutter speeds stop motion.  Note that a faster film allows for shorter exposures.

Aperture

The aperture is like a valve that controls how much light goes through the lens.  Wider apertures (smaller f numbers) allow more light in (and allow for shorter exposures).  Wider apertures also produce more narrow depth of field (focus) and smaller apertures make for wide depth of field.

 

 

Is this article useful to you?  If you think so, please consider a voluntary donation.

More about donations!